Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Poll - Next Labour Party Leader

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    No one can ever win this "what Brexit stance would have won" argument, tbh. All would have lost votes somewhere and gained a few somewhere else. And the circumstances and mood music of 2019 were different to those of 2017, to Labour's disadvantage. None had the beguiling, dishonest simplicity of "Get Brexit done".

    Comment


      Especially with Laura Kuennsberg and Norman Smith on backing vocals

      Comment


        But it wasn't the strategic thing to do to win votes. My basis for saying that is the results of the Euros, where Labour's previous policy saw them getting 13.7% of the poll.

        Comment


          Euro elections aren't much of a guide to general elections though. Never have been, and certainly weren't last year. Remind me how the party that topped the polls in the Euros did at the GE? How many seats did they win in December, standing on the exact same platform as in May?

          Comment


            That's easy. They won 365

            Comment


              Exactly. They became an informal coalition with the Tories.

              E10, I accept that point to an extent. But it still doesn't answer the question of how it is clear that Labour would have done better sticking to their previous policy. Such information as we do have points to the opposite. And it was that information that forced Labour to make a change.
              Last edited by Lucy Waterman; 14-01-2020, 14:43.

              Comment


                How did the LibDems get on?

                Comment


                  They fell of a cliff because a lot of their support went to Labour after the policy changed.

                  Comment


                    htthttps://twitter.com/davidgraeber/status/1216818312778264576?s=20ps://twitter.com/davidgraeber/status/1216818312778264576?s=20

                    Comment


                      https://twitter.com/TomLondon6/status/1217008155282100224

                      Comment


                        Originally posted by Lucy Waterman View Post
                        They fell of a cliff because a lot of their support went to Labour after the policy changed.
                        In fairness they fell off a cliff because they were pretty rubbish in every way, were led by someone quite unbelievably hopeless (even when compared with the people she was up against) and seemed determined to alienate everyone who even thought about supporting to them. And yes, I did vote for them.

                        Comment


                          [URL]https://twitter.com/ta_mills/status/1217110682262495240?s=21[/URL]

                          Comment


                            Don't do it, Tom. You're playing into the Blairites' hands.

                            Comment


                              Of course in Tony Blair’s day antisemitism meant caricaturing and stereotyping Jews and it was unknown something Alistair Campbell made a bit of a habit of.

                              [URL]https://twitter.com/uncoolbob/status/1189161784172797953?s=21[/URL]


                              jess Phillips hiring Neil Kinnock’s daughter and Jack
                              Straw’s son.

                              straw got a CBE fr his work in losing the referendum

                              [URL]https://twitter.com/boulezian/status/1217131362915880963?s=21[/URL]

                              Comment


                                Of course in Tony Blair’s day antisemitism meant caricaturing and stereotyping Jews and it was
                                unknown
                                something Alistair Campbell made a bit of a habit of.
                                Ah, the proud tradition of Labour leaders innocently failing to recognise large anti-Semitic images emblazoned on walls.

                                In both cases, the people involved denied malign intent, and are fervently believed by their supporters while everyone else says come off it.
                                Last edited by Lucy Waterman; 14-01-2020, 17:35.

                                Comment


                                  Originally posted by Lucy Waterman View Post

                                  Ah, the proud tradition of Labour leaders innocently failing to recognise large anti-Semitic images emblazoned on walls.

                                  In both cases, the people involved denied malign intent, and are fervently believed by their supporters while everyone else says come off it.
                                  And of course in both cases the vast majority of people are somewhere between the two ends of that continuum

                                  Comment


                                    That’s fair, AH. And most people probably don’t give a toss or know about either.

                                    Comment


                                      Originally posted by Nefertiti2 View Post
                                      Jess Phillips hiring Neil Kinnock's daughter and Jack
                                      Straw's son.

                                      Straw got a CBE fr his work in losing the referendum
                                      Straw Jr accepted his gong with some attempted deprecation about his girlfriend fancying a day out at the Palace, IMS. What an absolute arsehole. Both sides had their share of people to whom it was all just a game.

                                      Comment


                                        He also lost a marginal seat. Laughable award.

                                        Comment


                                          Originally posted by Lucy Waterman View Post


                                          Ah, the proud tradition of Labour leaders innocently failing to recognise large anti-Semitic images emblazoned on walls.

                                          In both cases, the people involved denied malign intent, and are fervently believed by their supporters while everyone else says come off it.
                                          Although Corbyn asked a dumb question on someone's facebook page- he didn't paint the mural.

                                          Campbell not only commissioned a blatantly anti-semitic image he told the BBC to fuck off when they raised the matter.

                                          Happy days....

                                          Comment


                                            I see Starmer has a diverse team in his campaign camp, including the wishy-washy Labour First faction national co-ordinator (who I know). Be interesting to see if the press give him a relatively easy ride (until the leadership campaign concludes, at least). I’m still hoping a RLB/Raynor ticket comes in, but it’s not looking likely right now.

                                            Comment


                                              And with any luck this will fuck Lisa Nandy's campaign down the toilet, exposing her as an apologist for fascism


                                              https://mobile.twitter.com/MhairiHun...06864709971969


                                              Comment


                                                I see both anti-Scottish sentiment and anti-Catholic dog-whistling are becoming a feature of this campaign. Going well innit …

                                                Comment


                                                  Time to start hating on the Welsh.

                                                  Comment


                                                    Originally posted by E10 Rifle View Post
                                                    I see both anti-Scottish sentiment and anti-Catholic dog-whistling are becoming a feature of this campaign. Going well innit …
                                                    The pundit class are working overtime to minimise it. An absolute belter from Ian Dunt.

                                                    https://twitter.com/flying_rodent/status/1217800941774176256

                                                    Comment

                                                    Working...
                                                    X