How good does this look like it's going to be?
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri
Collapse
X
-
I think they've finally got around the fact that they don't have to have a lead male. Both Rockwell and Harrelson are nominated for best supporting actor in the BAFTAs.
Best supporting male was Peter Dinklage, he was the one holding the ladder after all.
Comment
-
- Mar 2008
- 20987
- The House with the Golden Windows
- Fast falling out of love for football.
- WasPlain Hobnobs
Not really.
I'd like one or other to win.
But not nominated for Baftas anyway.
But back on topic.
Come on people - hand over your credit cards to your local multiplex and go and see it.
If you are disappointed, let me know and I will refund your admission by donating it to the RNLI.
Comment
-
I liked it, if maybe not quite as much as I was expecting to. Certainly not as much as In Bruges, The Guard and Calvary (if we’re going to lump both McDonagh’s brothers films together), all of which I loved.
It’s not really the black comedy it’s been marketed as and is more of a tragedy leavened with some really strong humour. The comedic moments in the trailer seem to be all the ones that are in the film at all and the rest is largely bleakness. Luckily, I had already read and heard in reviews that it may not be the film you would expect.
All of the main performances were great except Abby Cornish’s whose accent bothered me immensely - was she doing it in her own or trying another one? If it was the former, it needed some explanation. If it was the latter it was a disaster.
Comment
-
Did you see Sam Rockwell's dad's comment in the NYT: https://slate.com/culture/2018/01/sa...-all-time.html
Comment
-
Saw this last night at a virtually empty local Odeon multiplex. Really enjoyed the acting (apart from Abbie Cornish’s bizarre wandering accent) and the dark humour. Some of the violence was shocking, & I get some of the bubbling criticism of Sam Rockwell’s character’s partial redemption arc, but as so much of the plot development concerned unresolved events and a lack of clear-cut goodies/baddies, I think it’s being simplistically overplayed.
Comment
-
I saw this yesterday, and I thought it was brilliant, in a 'greater than the sum of its flaws' kind of way.
I take what Reginald says about the comedy detracting from the darkness of the material, but my main criticisms would be a) that there were too many characters with a 'big story', and b) some of the great lines, especially those given to McDormand, were so obviously set-pieces, shoehorned in because McDonagh wanted to go off on a little side-rant. I read about the scene with the Catholic priest getting a standing ovation in some cinemas, and I can't help thinking that was its main point, as opposed to advancing plot or character or anything.
In terms of comparison, the film I was most thinking of when I left the cinema was In the Bedroom, from 2001. Not surprising perhaps, as parents grieving murdered children were the central motif in that as well. In the Bedroom, especially Sissy Spacek's performance, still moves me when I think of it now, 16 years later, though its ending was actually way inferior to Three Billboards'.
Comment
-
That Independent article makes some thought-provoking points. However, if you also want to make casual reference to lazy directing, you should be extra careful to avoid the kind of lazy writing that leaves the impression you completely misunderstood the film's ending.
Comment
-
- Mar 2008
- 29953
- An oasis in the middle of Somerset
- Bath City FC; Porthcawl RFC;Wales in most things.
- Fig roll - deal with it.
There is a lot to agree with and disagree with on this thread. I am not sure how the redemption of McDormand's character is OK while Rockwell's character isn't. While Mildred has a black boss who she is obviously friendly with and is respectful of Jerome, she is happy to use "nigger" in the conversation with Dixon (albeit that may be to wind him up). Also, she is vile towards Willoughby when he opens up to her about his cancer, firebombs a police station and kicks, at least, one child in the crotch. Her redemption is more gradual in the film when she is physically confronted by the reality of Willoughby's cancer, her reacting to Willoughby's letter and, ultimately, being taken to task by James. While Dixon's misdemeanours - both actual and alluded to - are more serious, his redemption is much more stark after Willoughby's letter and the kindness shown by Red.
My two reservations are, as mentioned, Abbie Cornish. Not only because her accent was dreadful but because she was just a terrible match for Harrelson. She's 20 years younger than him and looks it and there is no reason for her to be in the story. It felt a bit like Elizabeth Debicki's character in 'The Night Manager' but, at least in that, Hugh Laurie's character is a powerful rich man whereas Harrelson is just a town sheriff.
Also, I fall into the camp of thinking that the ending felt tacked on. It felt like them just going to drive to kill the guy felt too dark and ending so they asked for the ambiguity. I have heard it said that a few people have thought that there were two, maybe three places where it could have ended more satisfactorily and I agree with that. All this is small fry though as it is a great film. If "In Bruges" is a better film then I must get my arse in gear and watch it.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Bordeaux Education View Post
My two reservations are, as mentioned, Abbie Cornish. Not only because her accent was dreadful but because she was just a terrible match for Harrelson. She's 20 years younger than him and looks it and there is no reason for her to be in the story. It felt a bit like Elizabeth Debicki's character in 'The Night Manager' but, at least in that, Hugh Laurie's character is a powerful rich man whereas Harrelson is just a town sheriff.
Debicki’s character in ‘The Night Manager’ is pretty true to the book, she is meant to be a ridiculously attractive young trophy girlfriend.
BTW, the phrase “kicks at least one child in the crotch” has now made me crack up laughing out loud every one of the five times I’ve read it - especially when I’ve delivered it in a Maude Flanders voice.Last edited by Ray de Galles; 31-01-2018, 23:29.
Comment
Comment