There's a blizzard of four and five star notices cited in the ad on the back of last week's Guardian Guide. Maybe Iannucci's ever garlanded status has attracted an early backlash.
Hopefully Palin doesn't play Molotov like he did Himmler in the Mr Hilter sketch.
However, I don't get the issue with "comic actors." They are still actors; they have a craft. If they ham it up, it will be because they are being directed badly and not being told to rein it in, which they are perfectly capable of doing.
I've just got back from it and thought it excellent. The comedy is constantly placed in contrast to the sheer horror that is going on, and has been going on for twenty years. There is also a lot of stuff put into background or passing shots.
I had some degree of consternation about people laughing along with Beria but I guess he couldn't be the only person without good lines.
Seen a couple of subtly snide articles about what a good family man one of the main cast is. Seems like newspaper editors think he's absolutely "super".
Thoroughly enjoyed it. I get what people are saying about laughing at horror, but you kinda know what you're getting into when you pays your money and takes your choice.
Jason Isaacs' playing of Marshal Zhukov with a Yorkshire accent was inspired.
I thought it was fantastic. The funniest film I’ve seen all year but incredibly blackly so obviously. There are some genuinely horrific moments and allusions, though they marry up with the comedy surprisingly well.
I thought the cast were excellent, matching the quality of the script (and sensed some improvisation in places) but Simon Russell Beale steals the show amongst the established comic turns.
I’ve just realised what it reminded me of and one of the reasons I enjoyed it so much - it’s like a very dark, profane Marx Brothers movie. I mean that as very high praise.
Hoping to see it during the week. Simon Russell Beale was very good as Stalin in a play called Collaborators at the National Theatre a few years ago. That had some very dark humour in it and it'll be interesting to see how they compare.
I thought the cast were excellent, matching the quality of the script (and sensed some improvisation in places) but Simon Russell Beale steals the show amongst the established comic turns.
Oh, I've never seen or heard him outside of Radio 4. Look forward to that.
Very good indeed, particularly Buscemi and Simon Russell Beale as Beria. And the cockney Stalin was funny. But Jason Isaacs really does steal the show.
I'm clearly in a minority here, but I found it really underwhelming and just not very funny at all. So I gave it a second go... and the same. And I both like and (think I) understand Iannuci's type of humour which I expected to fit marvelously with this sort of material. This one just didn't work for me, for reasons I find difficult to grasp.
Seen a couple of subtly snide articles about what a good family man one of the main cast is. Seems like newspaper editors think he's absolutely "super".
Just saw this on a flight, loved it. There is that inner conflict about laughing at horrific brutality. But these men probably really were ridiculous; it was just collective fear which kept them in power. Wonderful performances but have to agree on Jason Isaacs.
Test your moral compass by your gut reaction to the final section.
I thought it excellent, and it raised very many smiles but no laughs.
The bit with the little girl - I had that image as a screensaver for a while in the 90s, and in a frame for ages. Had to explain why several times; it’s the juxtaposition of innocence/evil, and its iconic status. So much going on in that photo.
Janik, you're not the only one. Good acting, finely scripted but not up to the mark. A cross between satire (requiring intelligence) and slapstick (no more than a poke in the eye) that fell flat on both counts.
Comment