Everybody hated Wilma. Attorneys, clients, defendants and prosecutors, other judges. She was a squat Navajo spinster with a face like a bulldog licking piss off a cactus. She was also a dry drunk. If she fell off the wagon the night before God help Magistrates Court next morning because she would be nursing a hangover. If she stayed on the wagon it was the same. Bad tempered and rude. All her decisions were arbitrary and bore little relationship to the law.
Everybody hated Wilma but the difference was that Wilma hated me. She thought I was stroppy and pushy because I wasn't afraid to pull her up when she was wrong which was often. Others did too, of course, but she took exception to me. Maybe it was the accent.
I was assigned to defend a woman who was charged with ADW and spousal abuse. Her mean spirited, no account husband had come home drunk from a night of whoring once too often and she laid him out with his own guitar. She was in Court to be committed for trial. The case was called and I entered my appearance.
"The defendant has no address in the file. Is this an oversight or is the defendant homeless?"
"No. Not homeless Judge."
"Then why no address?"
"The defendant may be at risk from the complaining witness Judge. Pursuant to NM Code.... I am not required to present an address in open Court if there are reasonable grounds to believe that a party may be at risk. I respectfully decline to give the address in open Court."
"Just read out the address Sir!"
"Pursuant to NM Code...."
"You've said that already. This is my last time of asking. If you don't answer you will be cited for contempt."
"Pursuant to...."
"I am citing you for contempt. Officer, arrest this man."
"Judge. The relevant statute is not for reinterpretation by a lower court." She looked like she was about to explode. "I will not divulge the address. Lock me up if you please."
As I was about to be hauled in irons out of the courtroom Scotty rose and entered his appearance. He asked for five minutes to talk with me. "What the fuck are you thinking?"
"I don't want that address in an open court file Scotty. He is a violent man with a large violent family and she has kids."
At that point I was hauled off to jail.
I wasn't there long. Three hours as our office took the matter immediately to the Chief Judge of the district who had no time for Wilma. Did my standing no end of good. Word got around. Suddenly I was the lawyer who was prepared to go to jail for his clients.
Scotty wasn't put in the dilemna that I was. Wilma continued the case for 2 days for 'reflection'. When it came back it was dismissed.
Everybody hated Wilma but the difference was that Wilma hated me. She thought I was stroppy and pushy because I wasn't afraid to pull her up when she was wrong which was often. Others did too, of course, but she took exception to me. Maybe it was the accent.
I was assigned to defend a woman who was charged with ADW and spousal abuse. Her mean spirited, no account husband had come home drunk from a night of whoring once too often and she laid him out with his own guitar. She was in Court to be committed for trial. The case was called and I entered my appearance.
"The defendant has no address in the file. Is this an oversight or is the defendant homeless?"
"No. Not homeless Judge."
"Then why no address?"
"The defendant may be at risk from the complaining witness Judge. Pursuant to NM Code.... I am not required to present an address in open Court if there are reasonable grounds to believe that a party may be at risk. I respectfully decline to give the address in open Court."
"Just read out the address Sir!"
"Pursuant to NM Code...."
"You've said that already. This is my last time of asking. If you don't answer you will be cited for contempt."
"Pursuant to...."
"I am citing you for contempt. Officer, arrest this man."
"Judge. The relevant statute is not for reinterpretation by a lower court." She looked like she was about to explode. "I will not divulge the address. Lock me up if you please."
As I was about to be hauled in irons out of the courtroom Scotty rose and entered his appearance. He asked for five minutes to talk with me. "What the fuck are you thinking?"
"I don't want that address in an open court file Scotty. He is a violent man with a large violent family and she has kids."
At that point I was hauled off to jail.
I wasn't there long. Three hours as our office took the matter immediately to the Chief Judge of the district who had no time for Wilma. Did my standing no end of good. Word got around. Suddenly I was the lawyer who was prepared to go to jail for his clients.
Scotty wasn't put in the dilemna that I was. Wilma continued the case for 2 days for 'reflection'. When it came back it was dismissed.
Comment