Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Anyone for an astronomy thread?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Speaking of twee earth science stuff, that "A Day in the Life of Earth" thing the other day was proper rubbish. The 24 hours conceit was completely pointless, the framing device was a series of cringingly scripted encounters with imaginary people, and they spent most of the budget on bad CGI to repeatedly convey the idea "this number is really big".

    Comment


      Originally posted by The Awesome Berbaslug!!! View Post
      I was wondering whether anyone else noticed this in the news. It's quite spectacular once you see it graphically, how far it's ventured.

      And hobbes, is it true that on a perfect sundown (I think I read down, not up), that you can see MIR swishing by on the horizon without using any goggles or scope or anything?

      Comment


        It may be time to finally say goodbye to Opportunity. It was supposed to be finished after 90 days in april of 2004, It lasted to june of 2018.

        then again

        Comment


          Originally posted by Pietro Paolo Virdis View Post
          And hobbes, is it true that on a perfect sundown (I think I read down, not up), that you can see MIR swishing by on the horizon without using any goggles or scope or anything?
          Sorry. Missed this at the time. You definitely can't see MIR as it took a dive into the atmosphere back in 2001-ish.

          Do you mean the ISS?
          In which case if it's going over you at night you can see a fast moving, bright object travelling from horizon to horizon, West to East in about 10 minutes, every 90 mins. It won't be distinguishable as the ISS though. To see the shape you need binoculars (which is hard as it moves fast.) alternatively if you know it's passing across the moon, and you time it right you can get a shot of it. Google "ISS moon transit" to see some shots. I can't figure out how to embed Google images anymore.

          First time I ever used my solar scope the ISS went across the face of the sun, which was amazing to see. I had no idea it was going to.
          Last edited by hobbes; 04-02-2019, 08:53.

          Comment


            The Lake District has started the process of becoming a Dark Sky area, or whatever it's called. Exmoor's already done this. I assume it doesn't entail everyone in Aspatria having to blackout their windows at night, but I'm not sure.

            Comment


              I'm pretty sure I once saw the ISS, I was out for a hike on the moors above Chorley. It was towards the end of the day and I saw this bright object in the sky going at great speed, much faster than a plane and no contrails. Is it even possible?

              Comment


                <Outer Limits music>

                Comment


                  Originally posted by Moonlight shadow View Post
                  I'm pretty sure I once saw the ISS, I was out for a hike on the moors above Chorley. It was towards the end of the day and I saw this bright object in the sky going at great speed, much faster than a plane and no contrails. Is it even possible?
                  well it's doing 17,000 miles an hour, and you can see it at dusk.

                  Comment


                    Oh good, looks like it really was the ISS then! It was sparkly I remember, solar panels I guess...

                    Comment


                      It goes around the world once every hour and a half.

                      Comment


                        Was it sparkly the whole time of just for 30 seconds or so?it could have been an iridium flare.

                        Comment


                          Those are apparently quite common for amateur astronomers to see. If it was between the end of January, and the end of March last year it might have been the humanity star, launched by New Zealand company rocket lab. It was basically a disco ball. This kind of pissed off a lot of people.

                          Last edited by The Awesome Berbaslug!!!; 05-02-2019, 01:44.

                          Comment


                            Is that about to inseminate Julie Christie? (The thing on the left)

                            Comment


                              NASA say goodbye to Opportunity

                              The last message they sent it was This song. I think they may have grown inappropriately attached to the intrepid little explorer.

                              Comment


                                Hasn't Elon Musk announced a rescue plan yet? Cunt.

                                Comment


                                  There's a French TV show about that. Probably best if he doesn't, if that's anything to go by.

                                  Comment


                                    I'm getting 'Video Unavailable' for that Youtube link, TAB. What is it?

                                    Comment


                                      Billy Holiday singing "I'll be seeing you." Judging by the various other names for that piece when I was looking for it, it appears to have been used in a movie called the Notebook .

                                      Comment


                                        Heh, speaking of Musk, he seems to have calmed down a bit, after his ground breaking research in how to break as many laws as possible through twitter. The issues at tesla seem to revolve not around the Ground breaking or electric side of things, but with the much more old fashioned problems of the industry, of how to make a large number of vehicles as quickly as possible. Just the basic nuts and bolts of running a car factory. This side of things isn't really an issue over at SpaceX. It's important to remember he doesn't really run SpaceX. SpaceX is run by an extremely capable President and Chief operating officer named Gwynne Shotwell. She is the one who manages to keep all the multiple plates spinning in the air. If Tesla had someone like her in a similar position, things would be running a lot more smoothly.

                                        As regards doing actual things, Space X are about to launch their crew capsule up to the ISS at the end of the month, as the first phase of testing. Then in a couple of months, they're going to blow up a rocket in mid air to test its escape mechanism, and that going well they're going to be sending the first humans up by the end of the year. When that's done, they will have completed all development on their Engine, Boosters and capsules. The only thing other thing that is left is figuring out how to catch their fairings in a giant net. Those things cost $6 million for a set. Carbon Fibre is Fucking expensive as we're about to see. They're severely allergic to sea water, and though they're getting a lot closer, "nearly" is not enough.

                                        They recently laid off 10% of their workforce (700 workers) But that is a side effect of two things. The first is that they don't need to make quite so many rockets any more now that they can use them multiple times. But they also found themselves with a whole load of Carbon Fibre Specialists that they no longer needed because, they have given up on using carbon Fibre, which was going to be one of the most challenging aspects of building a rocket ship that can go to Mars. Carbon Fibre is really fucking awkward to work with and incredibly expensive, and what SpaceX were planning on doing would have required them learning an awful lot of new things about making large things out of Carbon Fibre.

                                        Instead they're going to build the thing out of Stainless steel, and instead of coating it with a heat shield, they're going to cool it by a) making it shiny which gets you a surprisingly long distance. B) there's going to be a double hull with the outer hull perforated in tiny holes, and when the time comes to enter an atmosphere, they're going to pump liquid methane into the gap between the hulls, which will absorb a lot of the heat, and evaporate through the holes taking more heat away. It may be a little bit heavier than using Carbon Fibre, but it's going to be a hell of a lot better suited to sitting around on the surface of mars for two years, and it's considerably more robust. Also instead of scraping off and spraying on a new heat shield, You will be able to repair it by spraying it in wd-40. Indeed, cleaning stainless steel space ships is exactly the thing that wd-40 was developed to do.

                                        The other thing is that it's about 2% of the cost per Kilo. The Figure quoted for the type of specialist alloy SpaceX are going to use is about $3 a kilo. Carbon Fibre is about $180 a kilo, and that doesn't take into account how much of the shit you wind up throwing away.(because you're essentially laboriously making a giant "cloth" of carbon fibre, cutting out your shape like a tailor, putting it on a mould, and then baking it in a high pressure oven that would be bigger than any built yet. And if you don't get it perfectly right, you have to throw the whole thing out, on top of all of the "Tailor's off-cuts" from the original giant cloth.) It's also incredibly fucking slow. On the other hand, most of the issues surrounding the use of stainless steel in rocket design were overcome in the 1940's, and someone recently solved a lot of the remaining ones. So this is a huge step forward in building this thing. It's gone from a whole list of extemely expensive imponderable engineering and material science challenges, down to "Can you build two big tanks out of stainless steel, wrap a metal hull around them, and hook up the plumbing to the engines?"

                                        The other big thing is that instead of developing the full power, and vacuum version of their engines, they decided to settle on a single intermediate engine, and develop those final versions later. They're already testing a full size version of that engine, and did the first test during the Superbowl, and it passed that most crucial of stages, namely, starting and shutting down without turning into a cloud of razor sharp shrapnel. They've been testing it all week for increasingly longer periods of time, and it's already above their targets needed to make the thing work In a couple of months time, they're going to put three of them in that metal ship I posted up a couple of weeks ago, and are going to practice flying it around and landing. This is definitely happening, and it's going to happen sooner rather than later. Not because we're going to Mars, but because there is a commercial demand to use it in the short to medium term.

                                        Comment


                                          SpaceX's Crew Dragon is about to reenter the atmosphere. Fingers crossed.

                                          Comment


                                            Successful splashdown!

                                            Comment


                                              Incidentally, this...
                                              Heh, speaking of Musk, he seems to have calmed down a bit, after his ground breaking research in how to break as many laws as possible through twitter.
                                              ... seems to have been spoken too soon. Since then Musk tweeted out and later had to correct an inaccurate production forecast, prompting the SEC to seek a declaration he is in contempt of court for breaching the settlement.

                                              Comment


                                                yeah I saw that. He seemed to confuse the annualized rate they would be at at the end of the year, with the amount of cars that they would build in that time. That's the sort of slip you can get away with when you're talking about a private company and thrust metrics etc. but a public company is a very different thing altogether.

                                                There was considerable consternation this week when the NASA chief administrator Jim Bridenstine, essentially stabbed the SLS and the mostly republican Congressional Shuttle coalition right in the face. It seems that one of the strongest and most durable parts of the military industrial complex is literally nothing to Donald Trump and his need for spectacle.

                                                Trump is weird about space. Space Force being the prime example. It's a means for him to make cost free announcements that allow him to look like he's making america great again. NASA were in theory going to Mars under Obama, so under Trump they were going to go to the moon. (though there is a story where Trump offered NASA essentially unlimited money to put a man on Mars during the trump presidency. Now this essentially involved taking NASA's preexisting plans and adding talk of a lunar lander on top, and eventually turned into a series of missions to near the moon, Using the Huge, Incredibly expensive SLS rocket. This had the advantage of keeping Senate republicans happy. However the problem with the SLS is the problem that there's always been with the SLS. It's taking forever, and having been slated to launch in Obama's second term in office, it's not going to be ready to launch until 2021 at the earliest, and probably well after that.

                                                (A quick note about SLS. When the Shuttle programme was first slated to shut down after the second explosion, the Various members of congress representing areas involved in the Shuttle Programme started to come up with the idea of keeping the show on the road, by building rockets out of shuttle parts. That way the gravy train could carry on indefinitely. George W bush had the constellation programme. which was essentially the fruit of these efforts. It was shit, it was underfunded and overly expensive at the same time, it wasn't going anywhere, so Obama cancelled it, but the idea of keeping the shuttle industry going by building a huge rocket out of Shuttle parts was immediately resurrected as the SLS, with the senate stipulating that NASA build a giant rocket out of shuttle parts, and the Orion Capsule kept chugging along, with Obama allowing it slide in return for money to SpaceX and Orbital ATK for commercial cargo, and later Commercial crew, which is the programme that gave you the Dragon 2 that was flying last week)

                                                Now as always the issue with Trump is that he wants shit that makes him look like he's doing stuff, and this whole Space thing is going to ring a bit hollow if he doesn't have at least one little thing to show for it. So they desperately want the first mission to happen in June 2020. The First Mission is essentially to test the Orion Capsule ( started in 2006, current cost of development $18 Bn) to launch it up to orbit and send it on a trip around the moon and back, which will essentially be the Orion's equivalent of what SpaceX were doing with that launch up to the ISS. It was also supposed to act as the first launch of the SLS which would then allow them to declare that it was now safe and ready for humans. Indeed Trump asked if they could launch astronauts on the first launch, before being told politely that there wasn't a fucking chance in hell.

                                                However since SLS isn't going to be ready in time for a glorious Trump return to space, Bridenstine (at the insistence of Pence) has said that maybe NASA could launch the Orion on one commercial launcher (the Delta IV Heavy) and maybe launch an engine and fuel on another commercial launcher (Falcon Heavy), connect them up in space, (this is called distributed launch) and send that off around the moon. And that way NASA could MAGA. This is a brick in the face of the Shuttle Coalition, and Boeing in particular. Because the whole justification for building a fucking massive rocket is that you're not going to do distributed launch, and that everything is going to be launched in one go on a huge rocket. The second problem is that it is breaking the other unspoken law that the SLS will handle everything beyond Low Earth Orbit, and the third problem is that this means that all future launches of humans will be by this method, and not on the SLS. that has cut the number of potential launches for the SLS in half right there. This comes on top of the presidents budget request suggesting that NASA would probably consider shifting the launch of the Europa clipper mission from the SLS to the Commercial launch market. That's the first two missions wiped out right there. It's kind of impressive that while they seem to be harming Boeing by trying to ignore the grounding of their 737 planes, they were simultaneously kicking Boeing so hard in the spacenuts that everyone was wincing.

                                                Now there is no way on earth a democrat president could have done this, as it would have been shot down immediately just to spite him, but this is something that Trump wants, and he does not give two shits about Richard Shelby or Ted Cruz. What is alabama going to do? vote democrat? Go against el Caudillo? Are they going to expend all their political capital by having a huge row with the president over keeping crew on the SLS? or are they going to try and cling onto what's left, in the knowledge that if this works out, there's no reason why they won't be able to do every SLS launch in this fashion for a fraction of the price?

                                                Now if NASA was half as keen on the SLS as the Senate is, then they might easily be able to come up with some technical reason as to why this couldn't be done, and that would be that. But NASA fucking hate the SLS but see it as part of the cost of doing business, as the moment that NASA ceases to be a means of funneling Pork, is the moment that republican senators gut it with a chainsaw. However, the political pressure will be for them to find a way of doing this, and as things stand, they happen to have a Spare Delta IV Heavy that they could use.

                                                The Bizarre thing about all of this is that this is the method of going to the moon that they were going with initially, (Earth orbit Rendezvous) before they figured out a way to do it all with a single Saturn V. (Lunar orbit rendezvous) This approach is also how they were supposed to be doing things back in George W Bush's Day, which was replaced by some sort of Apollo approach for the SLS, and now we're back to Earth orbit rendezvous again. This switching or architecture is a key means of ensuring that you get to talk a lot about your administrations plans for space, and you're leaving office before you've had to spend any real money on it, and then the process can start again. The thing is that Trump is so fucking out there and crazy that he actually wants to be seen to do something, even if that involves smashing everything in his path.

                                                Comment


                                                  Space is the Place if yr Sun Ra. We're never going to do it properly, are we? So much spunked money for nothing, it's going to be nasty autocrat wanker regimes and Cosmic Disruptor East India Companies fighting proxy wars in our shitey solar system till this shitehole Terra rots completely and a few poor cunts are left stranded on even more blasted Mars.

                                                  i kinda Hope Musk loses the first space fought thermonuclear war over control of the asteroid belt, whatever happens.

                                                  Comment


                                                    In retrospect it's not surprising, but apparently Musk didn't have a single tweet vetted after the settlement with the SEC. What the hell is the board doing?

                                                    Comment

                                                    Working...
                                                    X