Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Athletics and Ancestry

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Athletics and Ancestry

    RTE showed a programme yesterday evening profiling the Irish participants of the Beijing Olympics. It was interesting but seemed to be mostly about lowering expectations and pointing out that to our athletes competing in finals and semi-finals was a great success.

    In the course of it it went into how genetics and envirnoment play a role in an athlete's development. Occassionally the language was slightly clunky but in a well intentioned way. Apparently there have been 500 times under 10 seconds in the 100m. Every single one of them has been run by a man of West African descent. No white man (that was the term used in the programme, I can't think of a better one) has ever run under 10 seconds.

    The thing that struck me about that is that I can't think of a famous runner from that region other Frankie Fredriks. All the others that I know are from North America, the Carribbean or the UK. Is it training and food science stopping West Africa becoming the sprinting equivalent of the long distance exploits of Kenya and Ethiopia?

    #2
    Athletics and Ancestry

    Nigeria's had a vast amount of good sprinters over the years, male and female.

    There's a Nigerian guy who has run 9.85 seconds for the 100m (can't think of his name at the moment).

    Comment


      #3
      Athletics and Ancestry

      Francis Obikwelu, who runs for Portugal.

      Comment


        #4
        Athletics and Ancestry

        I see Nigerians in World Championships and particularly in relays but the fact that I can't name a single one and you can't think of his name was kind of my point. Why are their sprinters only good and not outstanding?

        Comment


          #5
          Athletics and Ancestry

          Obikwelu has silver medals from both the Olympics and World Championships, and a number of European Championship golds.

          Comment


            #6
            Athletics and Ancestry

            Hieronymus of Hesselink wrote:
            Nigeria's had a vast amount of good sprinters over the years, male and female.

            There's a Nigerian guy who has run 9.85 seconds for the 100m (can't think of his name at the moment).
            Not really going to matter. The American (sorry, edited, how can I forget a name like Gay) would nominally be shithot, but Mr Bolt, is fucking unbelievable.

            Comment


              #7
              Athletics and Ancestry

              I'm getting tired of your facts Ursus.

              In fairness though, he has been based in Portugal since the age of 16.

              Comment


                #8
                Athletics and Ancestry

                Nil Arshavin wrote:
                I see Nigerians in World Championships and particularly in relays but the fact that I can't name a single one and you can't think of his name was kind of my point. Why are their sprinters only good and not outstanding?
                Presumably because the Yanks and Europeans plough a lot more money into their athletics programmes than Nigeria do. Or maybe they just have access to better drugs . . .

                Just had a quick check and there were three Africans in the 1992 Olympic men's 100m final, two in the 1996 final, one in the 2000 final and two in the 2004 final. A Ghanaian guy who made the 2000 and 2004 finals failed to finish the race both times.

                Incidentally Obikwelu is not the Nigerian who has run 9.85 seconds, that is Olusoji Fasuba. Obikwelu has done 9.86.

                Comment


                  #9
                  Athletics and Ancestry

                  2006 Commonwealth Games 100m Final:

                  1 Asafa Powell Jamaica 10.03 s
                  2 Olusoji Fasuba Nigeria 10.11 s
                  3 Marc Burns Trinidad and Tobago 10.17 s
                  4 Uchenna Emedolu Nigeria 10.22 s
                  5 Aziz Zakari Ghana 10.22 s
                  6 Patrick Johnson Australia 10.26 s
                  7 Anson Henry Canada 10.28 s
                  8 Marlon Devonish England 10.30 s

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Athletics and Ancestry

                    Uchenna Emedolu won silver in 2002 too.

                    Comment


                      #11
                      Athletics and Ancestry

                      Commonwealth Games? Give me a break here Jorge. I'm not disputing that there ae good sprinters in Nigeria. I'm making the point that although the 500 best times in the 100m have been run by people of West African descent, the vast majority of those times were run by people who did not train there.

                      I found it interesting that to be at that level you need to have particular genes, top-class training and coaching and a world class diet and sports science.

                      Also mentioned was the fact that every Kenyan world class long distance runner was from the Rift Valley out of a population of about 2 million people. Even though Kenya has 16 million people, their athletes are in a specific region with 1/8th of the total population.

                      They made the point that long distance prowess is more due to practise and altitude because in general Kenyans and Ethopians have a different genetic structure but are still the best runners due to how much running they do at altitude.

                      Comment


                        #12
                        Athletics and Ancestry

                        Nil Arshavin wrote:
                        Commonwealth Games? Give me a break here Jorge.
                        Well apart from the USA, the Commonwealth Games has competitors from each and every one of those regions you listed here:

                        Nil Arshavin wrote:
                        The thing that struck me about that is that I can't think of a famous runner from that region other Frankie Fredriks. All the others that I know are from North America, the Carribbean or the UK.

                        Comment


                          #13
                          Athletics and Ancestry

                          The thing that struck me about that is that I can't think of a famous runner from that region other Frankie Fredriks

                          Are you talking about West Africa, or Africa in general? I only ask as Frankie Fredericks is Namibian, and that's in the south.

                          Incidentally, the only man with no African lineage to run the 100m in under 10s is this chap.

                          Comment


                            #14
                            Athletics and Ancestry

                            ... and he was 6th in the 2006 Commonwealth Games 100m

                            Comment


                              #15
                              Athletics and Ancestry

                              Nil Arshavin wrote:
                              I found it interesting that to be at that level you need to have particular genes, top-class training and coaching and a world class diet and sports science.
                              That's not surprising, though, really, when you look at the trend in sprint times over the last few decades. Something's changing, and it's not the athletes' genes.

                              I think the evidence is pretty good that West Africans are more likely to have a sprinter's musculature than people from many other parts of the world. Some people fight shy of this claim, thinking it racist, or that the implication is that this advantage is unfair, but I believe that's a mistake. However, a sprinter's musculature's not enough; you also need to be expertly trained and conditioned.

                              Comment


                                #16
                                Athletics and Ancestry

                                Incidentally, the only man with no African lineage to run the 100m in under 10s is this chap.
                                I'm shocked to have been misled by RTE.

                                Are you talking about West Africa, or Africa in general? I only ask as Frankie Fredericks is Namibian, and that's in the south.
                                I did think that myself, but figured it was to the South-West.

                                My jibe at the Commonwealth Games was more tongue in cheek to my point being smattered to pieces by yourself, HoH and ursus' points.

                                I did worry about coming across as racist or unfair in bringing this up. I wasn't particularly surprised by success being a combination of those factors but the fact that athletes in the richer countries have such a significant advantage over athletes with similar physical ability in poorer areas was a cause for concern.

                                Comment


                                  #17
                                  Athletics and Ancestry

                                  In terms of the volume of world class Sprinters, Nigeria come third after the USA and Jamaica.

                                  The issue is that Athletics is not as serious a sport in West Africa as it is in the West IndiesUSA and as such attracts less investment.
                                  If you are able to run 10.5 aged 15, you are more likely to take up a sport like football rather than athletics.
                                  There are numerous stories about Nigerian Strikers and wingers such as Finidi, Aghahowa, Martins, Amunike etc running 100m times that would put them at world class level when they are kids.

                                  Personally I don't think the fastest men in the world are sprinters and it is only those that are crap at Football, American football or Rugby (depending on what part of the world they grew up) that take up the sport.
                                  It isn't a very lucrative sport unless you are in the top 10 in the world and even then you earn peanuts compared to the other sports above i have mentioned.

                                  Jamiaica is the country that probably invest the most in the world when it comes to the sprint events (up to 400m) hence why they get such a stack of medals.
                                  They would probably get alot more if they young sprinters were not lured over to the USA and forced to play other sports.

                                  Comment


                                    #18
                                    Athletics and Ancestry

                                    It may have been mentioned and I overlooked it. It's pretty obvious to everyone that there's something about East Africans that make so many of them good at distance, and relatively crap at football, despite the massive popularity of the latter in those countries.

                                    So its not much of a stretch to think that West African people are naturally better at sprints (and football, for that matter).

                                    Does this mean, therefore, that there's an untapped gold mine of 800m talent in Chad and Central Africa?

                                    Personally I don't think the fastest men in the world are sprinters and it is only those that are crap at Football, American football or Rugby (depending on what part of the world they grew up) that take up the sport.
                                    I'm pretty sure the fastest men are sprinters, because they train so much for that specifically. But if you mean there are probably potentially faster athletes in other sports, then that might be true.

                                    I don't think football is quite comparble to American Football in this way. Football requires a lot of specialized skill and tatical instincts that must be developed from a young age, regardless of speed. However, a fast athletic kid can start playing American football for the first time when they're 16 or 17 and make it to the NFL, especially if they're also big.

                                    Comment


                                      #19
                                      Athletics and Ancestry

                                      Reed.

                                      "It may have been mentioned and I overlooked it. It's pretty obvious to everyone that there's something about East Africans that make so many of them good at distance, and relatively crap at football, despite the massive popularity of the latter in those countries."

                                      I think to be a long distace runner, you need certain physical characteristics. A slim build, small body and long legs.
                                      These physical characteristics are more prevalant (although not exclusive to) in East Africans and Mediterraneans hence why most of the best long distace runners are from East Africa, North Africa or SpainItaly.

                                      Big long distace runners are few and far between (Steve Cram and Walker from New Zealand are exceptions).

                                      Football is popular in East Africa, but they don't seem to produce top quality footballers and their Nations don't do very well in continental tournaments.

                                      "So its not much of a stretch to think that West African people are naturally better at sprints (and football, for that matter)."

                                      Better at sprints as the physical characteristics that make you good at sprints are more prevalent amongst people of West African Descent.
                                      I think having a sprinters build is an advantage for being a footballer, but it is way low in the list under skill and intelligence in the same way that being 7ft tall is an advantage in being a basketball player.

                                      "I'm pretty sure the fastest men are sprinters, because they train so much for that specifically. But if you mean there are probably potentially faster athletes in other sports, then that might be true."

                                      Thats what I was getting at.
                                      I guess those who show a turn of speed at say 14 but are either on the books at a premiership club or good high school running backs with the potential to go pro, are hardly likely to persue a career in Athletics.

                                      "I don't think football is quite comparble to American Football in this way. Football requires a lot of specialized skill and tatical instincts that must be developed from a young age, regardless of speed."

                                      Speaking from a UK context, most of the UK sprinters would have become footballers or Rugby players if their talent allowed.
                                      See Darren Campbell, Nigel Walker and Dwain Chambers as examples.

                                      Comment

                                      Working...
                                      X