Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
MLB 2019
Collapse
X
-
$5 million is apparently the maximum fine allowed, which makes me wonder why that is.
No punishment for any players involved. 1 year ban seems like a bit of a light punishment if there's nothing like a postseason ban to go along with it.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Incandenza View Post$5 million is apparently the maximum fine allowed, which makes me wonder why that is.
No punishment for any players involved. 1 year ban seems like a bit of a light punishment if there's nothing like a postseason ban to go along with it.
I wonder if Alex Cora is going to get a lifetime ban, as it appears that he was key to this operation and then took his "expertise" to Boston. He wasn't included in this set because MLB is still investigating the Red Sox.
Comment
-
- Mar 2008
- 7492
- Off the purple line
- I'm slutty: Roma (on haitus until Jose is fired), Liverpool, and Dortmund
- Del Taco
The experts on MLB Network (a good panel with Brian Kenny hosting, Tom Verducci, Bob Costas, Ken Rosenthal, and Dan O'Dowd) haven't speculated about a lifetime ban for Cora. They are using the these one year suspension as a gauge but not suggesting specific times but more than one year. Not that they seem to know anything that the rest of us don't. Man, Chaim has walked into a mess with the Red Sox (well over the luxury tax threshold, told to cut pay, weakened farm system, and now facing the need for a new manager either temporary or permanent). But they do have some time, whereas the Astros couldn't have expected these suspensions (and then to fire).
About half of the time for the panel has been spent discussing what should happen with tech going forward. I don't know why MLB hasn't moved to headset situations other than pitchers not liking the way the earpiece feels (which I don't want to minimize). Teams will try to cheat again even with these punishments. Players still juice even with stronger punishments. Using a headset means it would be very, very difficult to use tech to steal signs. The only sign stealing would be the already approved variety (looking for cues and clues from the pitcher).
About players: MLB was explicit after apple watch stuff that the clubs are the custodians of the game. And then there's the practical reality of a union defending players/no clear sense of which players did what. The players used the info. but didn't create the cheating system.
Comment
-
- Mar 2008
- 7492
- Off the purple line
- I'm slutty: Roma (on haitus until Jose is fired), Liverpool, and Dortmund
- Del Taco
And the fallout continues: Cora and Red Sox part ways by mutual consent.
MLB Now was fascinating today; the analysis was very insightful about Lunow (already disliked among most GMs and front office people), who is probably going to have a difficult time getting a job. The issue with Taubin (sp?) and the women reporters that we discussed previously in this thread was also highlighted in that Lunow set the tone for blaming the victims and never apologized to any of the reporters.
Hinch was discussed as being in an extremely difficult position. Cora and Beltran seemed to be the main drivers. If Hinch was too forceful, he could lose the room (esp. after a generally failed time managing Dbacks so having no real track record). So, Lunow needed to be the heavy. See what I just wrote--that wasn't going to happen. But then they showed a video from the playoffs this year during a press conference where Hinch told reporters that he would not talk about sign stealing since he had to answer questions yet unnamed sources were free from answering questions.
Finally, a clip was shown of Cora's press conference after London when the Yankees crushed the Red Sox. Cora noted that Beltran was the biggest free agent signing by the Yankees even if Beltran was working in the front office and that the Red Sox needed to be more careful with their work on the field. Cora smirked, which now has a very different meaning.
Dan O'Dowd was focused on the conceit of all of these guys and their drive to win overwhelming any sense of what is right.
And of course, we have teams that were already super powers, guaranteed to slaughter most other teams in the league and then piling on with this stuff. Too bad we don't have relegation in MLB.Last edited by danielmak; 15-01-2020, 04:27.
Comment
-
Post-season bans. I don't know why people aren't talking about that. I'm sure that people would say that it would be in effect punishing players on the team now for something that happened in the past, but there are two examples of teams who won the World Series after benefitting from cheating throughout the regular season and likely into the postseason as well.
The $5 million fine cap needs to be revisited. That's just ridiculous for calling results of games into question, and it's chump change for the owners.
Comment
-
A lot of rumors now that Altuve and others wore a patch that transmitted a signal to buzz to indicate the kind of pitch that was coming. May be a complete fabrication, but supposedly it's something that multiple parties said to different people.
Comment
-
- Mar 2008
- 7492
- Off the purple line
- I'm slutty: Roma (on haitus until Jose is fired), Liverpool, and Dortmund
- Del Taco
Beltran and Mets separate "by mutual consent." I think that would have been a tough road for a rookie manager, so the right move. Because he didn't start managing really, the Mets should have their choices. Red Sox and Astros (esp. the Astros) are going to need a veteran in my opinion. Supposedly the Astros have already interviewed Showalter and Gibbons.
Comment
-
- Mar 2008
- 7492
- Off the purple line
- I'm slutty: Roma (on haitus until Jose is fired), Liverpool, and Dortmund
- Del Taco
It looks like Dusty Baker will be the next Astros manager. I tend to buy the sentiment that he's not tactically very astute but I also buy the sentiment that he's very good with team building. The Nats were a mess other than during Dusty's tenure there and until this past season. And he's certainly done well with the teams he managed, but (to extend my first sentence) I think he gets only so far and then is usually out-managed when he's into the playoffs. Anyway, I think it's the right hire at the right time, although I would have gone with Showalter if I was the Astros. My sense is that Showalter's need to be in on everything, basically wearing out the front office, has settled with age.
Comment
-
He strikes me as just the guy to hire when you find yourselves in a crisis of your own making like this
He will make the environment as easy as possible for the players, is well liked by the media and has learned to appreciate the value of analytics.
Perhaps most importantly, he has zero connection with any of the shenanigans.
He's going to be spending a lot of time with the media, and I can see whey they thought he would be better in that role than Buck.
Comment
-
- Mar 2008
- 7492
- Off the purple line
- I'm slutty: Roma (on haitus until Jose is fired), Liverpool, and Dortmund
- Del Taco
Originally posted by ursus arctos View PostHe strikes me as just the guy to hire when you find yourselves in a crisis of your own making like this
He will make the environment as easy as possible for the players, is well liked by the media and has learned to appreciate the value of analytics.
Perhaps most importantly, he has zero connection with any of the shenanigans.
He's going to be spending a lot of time with the media, and I can see whey they thought he would be better in that role than Buck.
Comment
-
Got my London ticket, having not realised they'd gone on sale until yesterday. £134 for lower tier outfield, which I'm not too happy about but could have been worse. There were still £92 tickets left, but I was worried they'd be too far or too obstructed. At least with Wembley I know what the sightlines are like.
Comment
-
Didn't think they could afford to re-sign him. The heavy rumor is that over the winter they offered him $300 million and he countered with $420M.
It's Betts and David Price to LAD, Alex Verdugo to Boston, Kenta Maeda to Minnesota, and a pitching prospect to Boston, with a second deal dumping Joc Pederson on the Angels for an infielder.
Comment
-
- Mar 2008
- 7492
- Off the purple line
- I'm slutty: Roma (on haitus until Jose is fired), Liverpool, and Dortmund
- Del Taco
Originally posted by jefe View PostDidn't think they could afford to re-sign him. The heavy rumor is that over the winter they offered him $300 million and he countered with $420M.
It's Betts and David Price to LAD, Alex Verdugo to Boston, Kenta Maeda to Minnesota, and a pitching prospect to Boston, with a second deal dumping Joc Pederson on the Angels for an infielder.
Verdugo grew up a Red Sox fan so I'm sure he's happy.
Comment
-
Originally posted by ursus arctos View PostOf course they did
New York real estate types can't help themselves
If I'm Cohen, I squeeze them until they get out of the building as soon as the ink dries, rather than the ridiculous five year waiting period the Wilpons tried to force on them.
Comment
Comment