Originally posted by Bizarre Löw Triangle
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Calling an emergency session of the Central Committee of the AEB
Collapse
X
-
I think it's perfect. An excellent recruitment sergeant for the AEB. I had a conversation with my nephews about the folly of supporting England, they told me I don't understand, that things have changed etc.
Then the tweets came out and they have come around to my way of thinking. and the England shirts have been discarded.
Comment
-
And slightly more seriously - racism isn't caused by what happens in a football match. Young, likeable black footballers are subject to racist abuse cos racism, not cos penalties. "England to win all the time" is one of the least effective anti-racism strategies I've heard of, even in football, and that is in a world where Kick it Out exists.
Bad things happen around England games for lots of reasons, and different people will explain them differently. For me, "England" is a significant part of the reason.
(It's a funny old football where we're only allowed to wish one of two binary outcomes, and then the wishing must stop, and there's no wishing allowed about any of the details.)
- Likes 5
Comment
-
Originally posted by TonTon View PostAnd slightly more seriously - racism isn't caused by what happens in a football match. Young, likeable black footballers are subject to racist abuse cos racism, not cos penalties. "England to win all the time" is one of the least effective anti-racism strategies I've heard of, even in football, and that is in a world where Kick it Out exists.
Bad things happen around England games for lots of reasons, and different people will explain them differently. For me, "England" is a significant part of the reason.
(It's a funny old football where we're only allowed to wish one of two binary outcomes, and then the wishing must stop, and there's no wishing allowed about any of the details.)
Comment
-
Originally posted by TonTon View PostAnd slightly more seriously - racism isn't caused by what happens in a football match. Young, likeable black footballers are subject to racist abuse cos racism, not cos penalties. "England to win all the time" is one of the least effective anti-racism strategies I've heard of, even in football, and that is in a world where Kick it Out exists.
Bad things happen around England games for lots of reasons, and different people will explain them differently. For me, "England" is a significant part of the reason.
(It's a funny old football where we're only allowed to wish one of two binary outcomes, and then the wishing must stop, and there's no wishing allowed about any of the details.)
- Likes 1
Comment
-
Originally posted by TonTon View PostDifferent people will explain them differently, for sure. But yeah, there are huge problem with football's culture. Do you think that's an essential part of football? Perhaps.
- Likes 1
Comment
-
Yeah that seems reasonable, BLT. I think I'd make that "football's current culture" rather than "football", if it were going to be in my list. That is, you can't have England without "England", whereas you can have football without "Football", from your list, kinda thing. If that makes sense.
Comment
-
It's also ingrained in the men's game, and changing ingrained behaviour is very, very difficult. I don't really see too many groups or organisations in football who are willing to take on that challenge. For example, I think the FA's response to the booing and the online abuse should be to voluntarily play x number of games behind closed doors. Maybe the whole qualification campaign. Players are quite comfortable playing without the crowd now. It would show they were serious about dealing with the toxic culture within English football, and a good first step. Another thing would be allocating tickets to specific groups - 40% to families for example, a decent percentage to BAME supporters groups, cheaper tickets for under 25s etc, in order to try and reduce the percentage of 30-50 year white male fans who get pissed and cause trouble.
Comment
-
Originally posted by ooh aah View PostIt's also ingrained in the men's game, and changing ingrained behaviour is very, very difficult.
Comment
-
Originally posted by ooh aah View PostIt's also ingrained in the men's game, and changing ingrained behaviour is very, very difficult. I don't really see too many groups or organisations in football who are willing to take on that challenge. For example, I think the FA's response to the booing and the online abuse should be to voluntarily play x number of games behind closed doors. Maybe the whole qualification campaign. Players are quite comfortable playing without the crowd now. It would show they were serious about dealing with the toxic culture within English football, and a good first step. Another thing would be allocating tickets to specific groups - 40% to families for example, a decent percentage to BAME supporters groups, cheaper tickets for under 25s etc, in order to try and reduce the percentage of 30-50 year white male fans who get pissed and cause trouble.
It would have the added bonus of making tickets more accessible to everyone because without an away allocation there would need to be far more parity in ticket availability.Last edited by Bizarre Löw Triangle; 12-07-2021, 13:30.
Comment
-
Based on the following scoring system;
World Cup win = 5 points
Euros win = 4 points
World Cup runner-up = 2 points
Euros runner-up = 1 point
Here is where Football kicks it's feet back and is comfortable when it's in Europe:
Germany - 43
Italy - 34
France - 21
Spain - 18
Netherlands - 10
Czechoslovakia/Czech Rep - 9
Soviet Union - 7
England - 6
Portugal - 5
Denmark - 4
Greece - 4
Hungary - 4
Croatia - 2
Sweden - 2
Yugoslavia - 2
Belgium - 1
Comment
-
I imagine a triumphant cry of "it's coming to London!" would ruffle a few feathers from Cornwall to the North. Given Italy's well known regional divisions, will this line last? Does a pun beat provincial pride?
(not a very serious question, idle musing at best)
Comment
-
Originally posted by Janik View PostI would phrase it slightly differently, in that it is an ingrained behaviour that has attached itself to the Men's game. And has had that attachment for 50 years or so. Getting rid of it from Football could be done by changing the behaviour, or changing the attachment. Neither is at all easy, but there is little evidence that the FA are even attempting to given that the first step is calling it out for what it is which they are seemingly terrified or doing or just not interested.
Comment
Comment