Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Kathy Etchingham murders Jimi Hendrix biopic

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Kathy Etchingham murders Jimi Hendrix biopic

    This is the one with André Benjamin where the family of Hendrix refused original music to be played.

    From IMDb where Kathy (ex-girlfriend of Jimi) posted a review

    Yes it is garbage, 7 March 2014
    1/10

    The theatregoer hoping to get some insight into Jimi Hendrix and London in 1966/67 will leave the theatre disappointed. Before seeing the film I was apprehensive, as I had been told that my character was portrayed in a derogatory and potentially defamatory manner. I had been told that Jimi had beaten me with a telephone in the film and after I had protested that this was not true the film makers had replied that it was true because they had "thoroughly researched" me. In other words they were saying that they were telling the truth and I was not.

    During the opening scenes I found it difficult to comprehend the way the story was unfolding, or what it was depicting. The editing was disjointed and dialogue was layered on top of alternate dialogue, seemingly from a parallel conversation. The film progressed in a confusing and dull manner but there was one scene that gave me a momentary lift of anticipation. The scene depicts Jimi playing with Cream at the Polytechnic Students' Union and should have set out to depict an absolutely epic event that I had witnessed. (I had been carrying Jimi's guitar). I hoped that they would do Jimi justice in their interpretation of what happened. Unfortunately, once the music started, my heart sank. What a disappointment. Not only was it insulting to Jimi's legacy, but I would say it was fairly insulting to Eric Clapton as well because the real Eric Clapton would never have been in awe of the unremarkable performance presented to viewers in this film.

    The storyline progressed in an awkward and illogical way and was hard to comprehend. The basis seemed to be that the dimwitted "Jimi" could not make up his mind between the good rock chick (Linda Keith) and the bad rock chick (Kathy Etchingham) who later goes bonkers and takes an overdose. (If I was the actress having to play this lousy part wearing those ugly clothes I may have taken an overdose too.)

    Fictional characters were introduced that furthered the deluded political, racial and sexist agenda that John Ridley seemed to be pursuing. In particular Michael X was presented as a saintly black political guru whereas in truth he was a violent criminal con man who was executed for a gruesome murder. An "Ida" character is introduced who never existed in real life.

    The biggest disappointment of this film was that after expecting at least some kind of depiction of Jimi's humour and creativity and the amusing and creative times that were happening in London, instead we were shown a gloomy and depressing dark tale that pictured Jimi as some sort of moronic loser. Instead of showing Jimi touring the UK and Europe, writing and performing the most innovative music of the century we are shown scenes of banal mumblings, fictitious gratuitous violence and fictitious mental breakdowns and overdoses.

    My initial anxiety turned to scorn for the thoroughly bad screenplay and direction. I became bored and impatient for the end of the film. The fictional nature of the film left me feeling that the events I was watching were more akin to a made for DVD movie than a biopic. I felt that I wasn't watching an interpretation of the real events from the time, but rather a stiff and poorly depicted mashup of trivia from events described in my book, sprinkled over Ridley's racially driven fictional theme. Even the imaginary domestic violence and drug use that my character was involved in did not evoke the emotional response I expected, and I found myself feeling just as I have when watching other bad movies, impatient for it to just finish and spare me the indignity of having to watch another tiresome scene with wooden dialogue and disjointed editing. A short-sighted and somewhat offensive portrayal of Jimi and those around him at the time.

    Final verdict: Fictional Movie – 2/10 Biopic purporting to be based in fact – 1/10 (for spelling all the names right)
    Why on earth did Benjamin go ahead with this?

    #2
    Kathy Etchingham murders Jimi Hendrix biopic

    Oops, wrong place

    Comment


      #3
      Kathy Etchingham murders Jimi Hendrix biopic

      Was Michael X some twin brother I've not heard of?
      (not being serious)

      Comment


        #4
        Kathy Etchingham murders Jimi Hendrix biopic

        Disappointing. I'll give it a miss.

        Comment


          #5
          Kathy Etchingham murders Jimi Hendrix biopic

          Michael X committed one of the nastiest murders I've ever read about, comparable to the Manson murders. Not pleasant reading:

          http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gale_Benson#Murder

          Comment


            #6
            Kathy Etchingham murders Jimi Hendrix biopic

            Bloody hell, the time I interviewed Andre 3000 he'd just been cast in this thing. That was 11 years ago. I can't believe it's seen the light of day.

            Rock biopics are usually awful, though. I kind of want to see that Brian Jones one where the actor playing him hadn't heard of him until he was offered the part.

            Comment


              #7
              Kathy Etchingham murders Jimi Hendrix biopic

              Lucia Lanigan wrote: Rock biopics are usually awful, though. I kind of want to see that Brian Jones one where the actor playing him hadn't heard of him until he was offered the part.
              Most make the mistake of trying to squeeze someone's career into 90—120 minutes. They end up inevitably full of what Jon Ronson calls "Chubby? Hmm…" moments.

              The better ones usually focus on some defining event (I quite liked Backbeat, for example, which just covered the Beatles' period in Hamburg).

              Comment


                #8
                Kathy Etchingham murders Jimi Hendrix biopic

                I remember that the Ian Dury one (which I otherwise enjoyed) ended noticeably abruptly and unsatisfyingly at some point around 1981, i.e. ignoring the final 20-odd years of his life entirely.

                Comment


                  #9
                  Kathy Etchingham murders Jimi Hendrix biopic

                  Walk the Line worked brilliantly, and the Dury one didn't frustrate me.

                  I have an entire film in my head that covers just one day in a popstar's life, I think it works but am not a good enough writer to put it on paper well enough, that's frustrating. I'm seeing the actors playing it.

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Kathy Etchingham murders Jimi Hendrix biopic

                    Stumpy Pepys wrote: The better ones usually focus on some defining event (I quite liked Backbeat, for example, which just covered the Beatles' period in Hamburg).
                    I thought Backbeat was great and I am not a fan of the Beatles. The music really made that film as well. I also thought that "Walk The Line" was very good.

                    Comment


                      #11
                      Kathy Etchingham murders Jimi Hendrix biopic

                      The one about Lennon and Epstein, The Hours and Times (1991)

                      Comment


                        #12
                        Kathy Etchingham murders Jimi Hendrix biopic

                        Stumpy Pepys wrote: Most make the mistake of trying to squeeze someone's career into 90—120 minutes. They end up inevitably full of what Jon Ronson calls "Chubby? Hmm…" moments.

                        The better ones usually focus on some defining event (I quite liked Backbeat, for example, which just covered the Beatles' period in Hamburg).
                        Yes, and there's also the vexed issue of how to get authentic-seeming live performance across. Not easy.

                        I liked the Ian Dury one, but it did make me notice a trend of punk nostalgia-pornography in cinema that I can't quite get on board with. The message - pizzow! - that you just have to be yourself to get somewhere is nice in itself, but the truth is, you're reliant on circumstance. The Joy Division/Factory films were similar: you emerge from the cinema all charged up with nowhere to go, cause there aren't any council flats or terraces to live in for cheap, or any record industry fairy godmothers with access to proper TV, or a naive music establishment to be really different from. Those were unique situations which ultimately grew out of major historical events.

                        Comment


                          #13
                          Kathy Etchingham murders Jimi Hendrix biopic

                          But yeah, good on Kathy Etchingham for putting this all out there. It must be so frustrating to see the former hangers-on and media twerps misrepresenting you and your ex like that. Imagine it in your own life; you'd go apeshit. Even when he was alive, Jim Hendrix had the most bizarre projections sent his way, and they hardly improved once he joined the silent majority.

                          Comment

                          Working...
                          X