My request of the whotfers

[jason voorhees]

Didn't want to pollute the Who? thread, but if I can impose on everyone and ask people to just give star-reviews (out of 4) to each episode so I have some clue of what to expect. I already know most of the spoilers (dangling that thread to someone like me after each Saturday is like dangling crack in front of a crackhead, I mean it's like dangling a peaceful pacifist planet in front of a Dalek attack formation,) but please make this as efficient as possible.

Such as:

1-**
2-***
3-*
4-****

Thank you.

[KimCasey]

My request of the whotfers

I take it you mean merely this series? Because, obviously, no-one would be so much of a nerd to do them all. Oh, no.

Series "4", then:

1. That fat thing. **
2. Fires of Pompeii ***
3. Planet of the Ood **
4. Sontaran Strategy ***
5. Part II **
6. Doctor's Daughter ***.5
7. Wasp thing *
8. Silence in the Library ****
9. Part II ***.5
10. Mimimilaist episode ***.5
11. Turn Left ***.5
12. The Stolen Earth ****

So, IMO, following the pattern of the last series by ratcheting itself up in a major way in the 2nd half of the run, after an uninspiring first few episodes. Still the greatest thing on TV though - only Lost is in the same ball-park.

[Purves Grundy]

My request of the whotfers

1. That fat thing. **
2. Fires of Pompeii ****
3. Planet of the Ood ***
4. Sontaran Strategy **
5. Part II **
6. Doctor's Daughter ***.5
7. Wasp thing .25
8. Silence in the Library ****
9. Part II ***.5
10. Mimimilaist episode *****
11. Turn Left ***
12. The Stolen Earth ***.5

[Guest]

My request of the whotfers

1. That fat thing. **
2. Fires of Pompeii ***
3. Planet of the Ood **
4. Sontaran Strategy **
5. Part II **
6. Doctor's Daughter **
7. Wasp thing **
8. Silence in the Library ****
9. Part II ****
10. Mimimilaist episode ***
11. Turn Left **
12. The Stolen Earth ***

[jason voorhees]

My request of the whotfers

Thanks a bunch everybody. I can't wait.

[EIM]

My request of the whotfers

I only saw 'Turn lLeft'. The only othr one I've seen is 'Blink'.

If 'Blink' was a 5, then 'Turn Left' was a 3.

Don't mention it.

[Mumpo]

My request of the whotfers

That fat thing 2
Fires of Pompeii 3½
Planet of the Ood 3
Sontaran Strategem/part II 1½
Doctor's Daughter - a charitable 4
Wasp thing 1
Silence in the Library/part II 4
Minimalist episode 5
Turn Left 2

[Wyatt Earp]

My request of the whotfers

Where 5 is "Blink" and 1 is "The Shakespeare Code":

Partners in Crime 1½
Fires of Pompeii 3
Planet of the Ood 3
Sontaran Strategem/Poison Sky 2½
Doctor's Daughter 4
Unicorn/Wasp 1½
Silence in the Library/Forest of the Dead 4½
Midnight 4½
Turn Left 2½
Stolen Earth 3½

[David Agnew]

My request of the whotfers

Partners In Crime. **½
Fires of Pompeii ***
Planet of the Ood **
Sontaran Stratagem/The Poison Sky *½
Doctor's Daughter ***
Unicorn & The Wasp **
Silence in the Library/Forest Of The Dead ****
Midnight ****½
Turn Left **
The Stolen Earth ***

Although I'm expecting Journey's End to be a let down.

[Yoss]

My request of the whotfers

By and large the series has got better as it's gone on. (I rate Turn Left a bit higher than most here. And Stolen Earth, maybe though I don't want to judge it until I've seen the resolution.)

The Moffat double-parter was of course the highlight, though I don't think it's Moffat's best.

[jason voorhees]

My request of the whotfers

..and the season finale ?

[Guest]

My request of the whotfers

**